• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to footer
  • Add Event
  • Directory
  • Submit News

MyZA

Free Events Calendar and Business Directory

  • SA News
  • Contact
  • Submit News
  • Directory
  • Quickly Add Listing

Court setback for Special Investigating Unit’s bid to recover money

11 December 2020 By admin

The Special Investigating Unit tried to overturn a judgment in the Eastern Cape High Court on the basis of information gathered during its corruption investigation. Photo: Brian Turner via Flickr (CC BY 2.0)

  • The Special Investigating Unit applied to overturn a medical negligence judgment in the Eastern Cape High Court.
  • The unit said during corruption investigations it had discovered that the state attorney’s office had not done its job properly.
  • But Judge Bantubonke Tokota said the unit had no legal standing to intervene.

An attempt by the Special Investigating Unit to overturn a R9 million medical negligence judgment in the Eastern Cape High Court has failed. The unit said it had discovered during investigations into widespread corruption in the province that the state attorney’s office had not done its job properly.

But the judge refused to re-open the case, which was finalised last year.

In its unusual application, which came before Eastern Cape High Court Judge Bantubonke Tokota, the unit wanted an order rescinding all court judgments relating to the damages matter brought by an Eastern Cape mother against the MEC for Health.

This included a settlement of liability, an agreement to make an interim payment of R2.6 million to the mother and the final R9 million settlement, all of which were made last year. The claim was a result of negligence during an operation on her newborn baby which caused permanent damage.

The SIU, which is investigating maladministration in the state attorney’s office, claimed that the state had not been properly represented and had the evidence of an expert, a paediatric neurosurgeon, been led, the state’s case would have been bolstered.

But the Judge said the SIU did not have any legal standing to intervene.

“The unit contends that the case was mishandled and the defendant failed to call a crucial witness. But it has not set out any facts relating to this. It merely asserts that this failure has resulted in financial prejudice,” the judge said.

“The claim that the witness would have bolstered the defence’s case is based on speculation,” he said noting the expert, in his report before the trial judge, had actually said that the state was liable.

Judge Tokota said only an appeal court could allow the re-opening of cases, on appeal by parties involved at the trial.

“If organs of state with powers to investigate corruption and related maladministration were allowed to re-open cases in which they were not involved, it would bring about chaos and uncertainty.”

He said to grant the application would open the floodgate to endless litigation.

Judge Tokota said the unit, if it believed the trial had been handled recklessly, could attempt to recover damages from the State Attorney’s office.

“There may be merits in the suspicion of corruption in the handling of medical negligence cases, especially in the Eastern Cape, however cases are decided on facts and not suspicions.”

Judge Tokota ordered the unit to pay punitive costs, saying he found the founding affidavit “tiring, boring and irritating”.

© 2020 GroundUp. This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

You may republish this article, so long as you credit the authors and GroundUp, and do not change the text. Please include a link back to the original article.

Source: GroundUp





Previous: New advertising authority takes firm stand against quackery
Next: Sex work activists demand answers from Human Rights Commission





Filed Under: GroundUp Tagged With: GroundUp

RSS Events

  • C’est la vie! returns on TV5MONDE After twelve years of success in French-speaking Africa, the drama co-produced by Mediawan Africa and the NGO RAES joins the channel and platform of the international French-language broadcaster.
  • Mozambique’s Moreira Chonguiça Makes Ronnie Scott’s Debut With Two London Jazz Festival Shows
  • Soweto Gets a New Summer Lifestyle Festival as Sugar People & Friends Celebrates Its First Birthday
  • Deftones Setlist: What to Expect From Their 2027 Live Show
  • Hyde Park Corner Brings Out the Stars for This Year’s Spectacular Tree Lighting Celebration!
  • Step Inside: Prudential Center – Home of the New Jersey Devils
  • Exclusive November Imax Lineup Features Iconic Music Legend and a Hollywood Blockbuster
  • Kasi Republic Brings Kwaito, Kasi Cars and Ispantsula Style to Riversands Farm Village This Reconciliation Day
  • Festive Shopping Made Simple at Solly Kramer’s Parkhurst
  • LEDBox Hires Outdoor LED Screen Trailers with On-Site Crew

About admin

The one with a "My Complex" - incurable but fun. Grumpy, Cynical, Wise and Idiotic. I can also be found HERE.

Footer

Latest News from Africa

  • Prince Albert – the New King of Jazz
  • Eritrea: Independence Cup in Southern Region
  • President El-Sisi Follows-up on the Evacuation of Egyptian Citizens from Sudan
  • United Arab Emirates welcomes initiation of talks between Sudanese Armed Forces and Rapid Support Forces
  • Ghana’s regions: why creating new territories has caused problems
  • Uganda Red Cross Delivers Relief Aid to Kisoro Floods-Affected Communities
  • President Ramaphosa alarmed over conflict, violence in eastern DRC
  • Mental health: almost half of Johannesburg students in new study screened positive for probable depression
  • Dietary Supplements for Dogs and Cats: Enhancing Well-being
  • Midwives scramble to ensure safe deliveries amid violence in Sudan

RSS MyPR’s Free Press Releases

  • Concentrix South Africa Recognised for Talent, Innovation and Leadership at CapeBPO and BPESA Awards
  • Mpumalanga School Gets a Major Makeover Through Reinhardt’s Community Upliftment Initiative
  • Winning Koesister Recipe Gets a Festive Rooibos Twist
  • AMN Unveils Multi-Band, Multi Technology Radio Node to Accelerate Low-Cost Telecom Rollouts
  • D’vine Skin & Body Answers the Key Questions About Dermapen Microneedling

© 2026 MyZA · Port Elizabeth, South Africa | Privacy Policy | MyZA content usage