• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to footer
  • Add Event
  • Directory
  • Submit News

MyZA

Free Events Calendar and Business Directory

  • SA News
  • Contact
  • Submit News
  • Directory
  • Quickly Add Listing

Dismissal on suspicion is unlawful, says CCMA

10 March 2021 By admin

The CCMA has has found that the dismissal of a security guard who apparently failed a lie detector test breaches the Labour Relations Act and the Constitution.

  • The Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration has found that the dismissal of a security guard who apparently failed a lie detector test breaches the Labour Relations Act and the Constitution.
  • The test followed a number of incidents of theft at the supermarket where the guard worked along with 20 other security personnel.
  • The Commissioner found that the test alone could not justify the termination of one’s employment.
  • Commissioner Naidoo ruled that the guard’s dismissal was both procedurally and substantively unfair.
  • He ordered the company to pay him 12 months pay (R56,400) plus interest.

A security company’s decision to dismiss one of its guards after he failed a lie detector test breached the Labour Relations Act and the Constitution, the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration(CCMA) has ruled.

The company, Corporate Investigating and Veracity Assessment Pty Ltd, relied on a provision in the employment contract. But the arbitrator found this to be unlawful and suggested that the guard should instead have been given a hearing with corroborating evidence to prove his guilt or exonerate him.

Security guard Aaron Mlangeni started working for the company in 2012. In 2019 Mlangeni was assigned to work at a supermarket. As part of his employment contract, he was obliged to undergo random voice analysis examinations.

In January 2020, he was informed that he had “failed” his recent test and was found to have been deceptive and untruthful. During the test Mlangeni was asked if he had stolen from the supermarket, had helped someone else steal, if he knew of anyone stealing and if he had accepted a bribe to keep quiet about the theft.

The company told CCMA Commissioner Frank Naidoo that at that time, the supermarket was experiencing stock theft. Mlangeni was one of 20 guards at that site who were subjected to the lie detector test.

His site manager, John Mauku, told the hearing that he believed Mlangeni to be an honest person and believed that the only other guard who failed the test, “Douglas”, was the culprit.

However, Mlangeni was fired because of the employment contract which stated that “to be successful in the test is an inherent requirement” of the conditions of employment. And it was a “pledge” that Mlangeni had signed.

Mlangeni protested his innocence. He refused to sign a “go quietly” mutual separation agreement in which he was offered an ex gratia payment of more than R10,000.

In evidence, a company employee admitted that Mlangeni had not been subject to a misconduct inquiry because voice analysis examinations results would not have been sufficient to make a finding of guilt.

Commenting on the test itself, Commissioner Naidoo said it was materially flawed. Mlangeni had been asked 11 pointed questions, and no deception was indicated in seven of them, including the question “did anyone approach you and ask you to help them steal?”. And yet, it was concluded that he had “failed” and should be fired, which amounted to termination based on suspicion.

“Suspicion, no matter how justified, cannot be a fair reason for the termination of one’s employment,” said Naidoo, noting that even the company had conceded that the test alone would not have stood the test for a misconduct dismissal (after a hearing).

The belief by some of his direct bosses that he was an honest person appeared to have no bearing on the company’s decision to dismiss him.

Naidoo said Mlangeni was entitled to a fair process in terms of the Labour Relations Act. “Much more is required in terms of our standard of proof… the company bore the onus to establish these rather serious allegations clearly and distinctly, on a balance of probabilities and it failed to do so.”

Naidoo said “particularly appalling” was the company’s “enticement to go off quietly”.

He ruled that Mlangeni’s dismissal was both procedurally and substantively unfair, and ordered the company to pay him 12 months pay (R56,400) plus interest.

© 2021 GroundUp. This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

You may republish this article, so long as you credit the authors and GroundUp, and do not change the text. Please include a link back to the original article.

We put an invisible pixel in the article so that we can count traffic to republishers. All analytics tools are solely on our servers. We do not give our logs to any third party. Logs are deleted after two weeks. We do not use any IP address identifying information except to count regional traffic. We are solely interested in counting hits, not tracking users. If you republish, please do not delete the invisible pixel.

Source: GroundUp





Previous: Grimy, broken-down, neglected: can this be the Eastern Cape’s flagship hospital?
Next: Bystander killed in Wits student protests





Filed Under: GroundUp Tagged With: GroundUp

RSS Events

  • Step Inside: UBS Arena – Home of the New York Islanders
  • Step Inside: Canadian Tire Centre – Home of the Ottawa Senators
  • How to Request Tickets for a Show
  • Jhene Aiko Setlists: What to Expect at Her 2027 Tour
  • Three Zones, Not One Castle: Amused Plans Year-End Parties Around How Guests Arrive
  • C’est la vie! returns on TV5MONDE After twelve years of success in French-speaking Africa, the drama co-produced by Mediawan Africa and the NGO RAES joins the channel and platform of the international French-language broadcaster.
  • Mozambique’s Moreira Chonguiça Makes Ronnie Scott’s Debut With Two London Jazz Festival Shows
  • Soweto Gets a New Summer Lifestyle Festival as Sugar People & Friends Celebrates Its First Birthday
  • Deftones Setlist: What to Expect From Their 2027 Live Show
  • Hyde Park Corner Brings Out the Stars for This Year’s Spectacular Tree Lighting Celebration!

About admin

The one with a "My Complex" - incurable but fun. Grumpy, Cynical, Wise and Idiotic. I can also be found HERE.

Footer

Latest News from Africa

  • Prince Albert – the New King of Jazz
  • Eritrea: Independence Cup in Southern Region
  • President El-Sisi Follows-up on the Evacuation of Egyptian Citizens from Sudan
  • United Arab Emirates welcomes initiation of talks between Sudanese Armed Forces and Rapid Support Forces
  • Ghana’s regions: why creating new territories has caused problems
  • Uganda Red Cross Delivers Relief Aid to Kisoro Floods-Affected Communities
  • President Ramaphosa alarmed over conflict, violence in eastern DRC
  • Mental health: almost half of Johannesburg students in new study screened positive for probable depression
  • Dietary Supplements for Dogs and Cats: Enhancing Well-being
  • Midwives scramble to ensure safe deliveries amid violence in Sudan

RSS MyPR’s Free Press Releases

  • Sixteen Women, One Blueprint: Tedxjohannesburg Women Brings a Full Day of Ideas, Art and Connection to Sandton on 28 November
  • What to Look for When Choosing an Inclusive and Accessible Retirement Estate
  • Viro Solutions’ Custom-Branded Sandwich Box Earns a Finalist Medal at the 2026 Gold Pack Awards
  • Chilla açaí by Polpanorte Brings Brazil’s Original açaí to South Africa
  • From Bottle to Business – The Entrepreneurial Value of Glass Recycling

© 2026 MyZA · Port Elizabeth, South Africa | Privacy Policy | MyZA content usage