• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to footer
  • Add Event
  • Directory
  • Submit News

MyZA

Free Events Calendar and Business Directory

  • SA News
  • Contact
  • Submit News
  • Directory
  • Quickly Add Listing

Immigrants in JHB claim they are being denied health care

17 November 2021 By admin

Zimbabwean women told GroundUp that they dread going to local clinics such as Jeppe Clinic and Hilbrow Clinic, because they are asked for money upfront. One woman said she had to send her five-year-old, epileptic daughter to Zimbabwe late last year because she was struggling to get treatement for her in Johannesburg. Photo: Kimberly Mutandiro

  • Public law centres say policy changes made last year by the Gauteng health department are unconstitutional and regressive.
  • Asylum seekers, people with expired permits and undocumented immigrants are effectively being excluded from accessing most public health services.
  • To get health care they are being asked to first pay upfront fees they cannot afford.
  • The Gauteng health department says it treats everyone the same and asked for specific incidents.

Human rights organisations are concerned about policy changes affecting immigrants since the Gauteng health department gazetted them in June last year and issued a circular in May 2020.

According to the organisations, medical care is being denied to asylum seekers and refugees if they are undocumented or have expired permits, unless they can pay upfront fees.

Hlengiwe Mtshatsha of Lawyers for Human Rights (LHR) said, “The new fee structure is very high and foreign nationals end up being on the highest scale and are required to pay upfront.”

“People with expired or no documentation have complained of being charged the highest fees or being turned away. They are expected to pay as if they are in private hospitals even though they are in public ones.

“With no documents they cannot even enter into a payment plan and they are also expected to declare their income, which is difficult in most cases.

“Asylum seekers and refugees are also being affected, especially those with expired papers. All our efforts to engage with the department have been unsuccessful.”

Sibusisiwe Ndlela, an attorney from SECTION27, a public interest law centre, said that since March 2020 the organisation has had nearly 70 requests from immigrants trying to access health services. She said this influx of clients followed the circular.

Ndlela said there are regulations and policies with offending provisions that “need to be set aside”.

SECTION27 and LHR say immigrants in need of medical treatment, sometimes urgently, are being turned away at Hillbrow Community Health Centre, Yeoville Clinic, Charlotte Maxeke Hospital, Jeppe Clinic, Wits Academic Hospital and Kalafong Hospital (Pretoria).

Immigrants also complain that they are treated disrespectfully and insulted by hospital staff simply because they are not South Africans.

It is not the first time the Gauteng department has been accused of trying to exclude immigrants. A circular issued in January 2019 was withdrawn and heavily criticised for being not only a problem for immigrants but a threat to public health in general.

Ndlela says, “This circular is a an attempt to introduce the same position as was adopted in the circular that was withdrawn.”

The organisation has been writing to hospitals on a case by case basis.

She said the Gauteng Guidelines on Patient Administration and Revenue Management is both unlawful and unconstitutional. It fails to consider the provisions of the Refugees Act which says that refugees and asylum seekers have the constitutional rights to dignity and equality, and to access health care.

According to Ndlela, it also violates the National Health Act that requires the state to provide free primary health care services, and it is unconstitutional because it discriminates unfairly on the basis of nationality and documentation status.

SECTION27 is considering litigation since it believes the state has created a policy intended to exclude immigrants despite their clear legal entitlement to health care.

A woman who lives in Johannesburg and is undocumented says she is sitting with a bill for R35,000 after her four-year-old child spent eight months (June 2020 to January 2021) in Johannesburg General Hospital for burns. She says her child was discharged but still needs follow-up medical attention, but she avoids going back to the hospital because of demands for payment.

Earlier this year, she went to Helen Joseph Hospital for treatment for herself, but was asked to pay a R350 consultation fee first. She stopped going. “l would beg on the streets at the traffic lights and look for money to buy medicine at the local pharmacy. Even now l am not healed,” she said.

Another woman from Zimbabwe, who has been in South Africa for ten years, says she was denied maternal care at Jeppe Clinic while she was pregnant because she is undocumented. She gave birth in October.

“They kept turning me back, giving the excuse that l had no papers and l didn’t have any money. I was worried because my time was coming closer … When l went to Hillbrow Clinic at seven months they only gave me a card but did not even book me, told me never to come back,” she said.

She said when she went into labour she got herself to the clinic. She said she was insulted by staff, but they eventually called an ambulance. The birth was complicated and she had to have a cesarean.

Ndlela says that besided scrapping policies that exclude immigrants from accessing health care, the department needs to have a “sensitisation programme” to address xenophobic attitudes.

Foster Mohale, Gauteng Department of Health spokesperson, sent us mostly one line responses to our questions. He said, “We hear ad hoc reports all the time, but we don’t get sufficient information or evidence to enable us to investigate.”

He said the department treats immigrants and their children “the same as everyone else”.

But, says Ndlela, the Uniform Patient Fee Schedule, which sets out the applicable patient classifications and fees for hospitals, provides for full-paying patients and subsidised patients. (Full paying patients are liable for the full payment of hospital costs and fees; subsidised patients qualify for partial or full subsidisation by the state.)

The fees are means-tested, she explained. South African citizens usually are subsidised. Under the Uniform Patient Fee Schedule, SADC citizens, even undocumented ones, are subsidised — the same as South African ones. But under the controversial circular “only documented refugees are treated the same as South African citizens”.

Ndlela said this means that the circular excludes asylum seekers and undocumented SADC citizens from subsidies.

© 2021 GroundUp. This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

You may republish this article, so long as you credit the authors and GroundUp, and do not change the text. Please include a link back to the original article.

We put an invisible pixel in the article so that we can count traffic to republishers. All analytics tools are solely on our servers. We do not give our logs to any third party. Logs are deleted after two weeks. We do not use any IP address identifying information except to count regional traffic. We are solely interested in counting hits, not tracking users. If you republish, please do not delete the invisible pixel.

Source: GroundUp





Previous: Attacks, stock theft, shrinking pastures, drought and a lack of vets: Eastern Cape horse owners in dire straits
Next: JHB neighbourhoods battle without water





Filed Under: GroundUp Tagged With: GroundUp

RSS Events

  • Mozambique’s Moreira Chonguiça Makes Ronnie Scott’s Debut With Two London Jazz Festival Shows
  • Soweto Gets a New Summer Lifestyle Festival as Sugar People & Friends Celebrates Its First Birthday
  • Deftones Setlist: What to Expect From Their 2027 Live Show
  • Hyde Park Corner Brings Out the Stars for This Year’s Spectacular Tree Lighting Celebration!
  • Step Inside: Prudential Center – Home of the New Jersey Devils
  • Exclusive November Imax Lineup Features Iconic Music Legend and a Hollywood Blockbuster
  • Kasi Republic Brings Kwaito, Kasi Cars and Ispantsula Style to Riversands Farm Village This Reconciliation Day
  • Festive Shopping Made Simple at Solly Kramer’s Parkhurst
  • LEDBox Hires Outdoor LED Screen Trailers with On-Site Crew
  • From Busking to the Business of Music: MEX Opens New Doors

About admin

The one with a "My Complex" - incurable but fun. Grumpy, Cynical, Wise and Idiotic. I can also be found HERE.

Footer

Latest News from Africa

  • Prince Albert – the New King of Jazz
  • Eritrea: Independence Cup in Southern Region
  • President El-Sisi Follows-up on the Evacuation of Egyptian Citizens from Sudan
  • United Arab Emirates welcomes initiation of talks between Sudanese Armed Forces and Rapid Support Forces
  • Ghana’s regions: why creating new territories has caused problems
  • Uganda Red Cross Delivers Relief Aid to Kisoro Floods-Affected Communities
  • President Ramaphosa alarmed over conflict, violence in eastern DRC
  • Mental health: almost half of Johannesburg students in new study screened positive for probable depression
  • Dietary Supplements for Dogs and Cats: Enhancing Well-being
  • Midwives scramble to ensure safe deliveries amid violence in Sudan

RSS MyPR’s Free Press Releases

  • Mozambique’s Moreira Chonguiça Makes Ronnie Scott’s Debut With Two London Jazz Festival Shows
  • The Best Brands Don’t Keep Reinventing Themselves. They Deepen What They Own.
  • D’vine Skin & Body Compares Three Mesoestetic Peels for Anti-Ageing Results
  • D’vine Skin & Body Explains the Difference Between Bikini, Brazilian and Hollywood Laser
  • Alora Medical Wins National Innovation Awards

© 2026 MyZA · Port Elizabeth, South Africa | Privacy Policy | MyZA content usage