• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to footer
  • Add Event
  • Directory
  • Submit News

MyZA

Free Events Calendar and Business Directory

  • SA News
  • Contact
  • Submit News
  • Directory
  • Quickly Add Listing

Minister and Legal Practice Council oppose court bid by Zimbabwean-born law graduates

24 November 2021 By admin

South Africa’s Legal Practice Council (LPC) and the Minister of Justice are opposing a court bid by three Zimbabwean-born graduates to change legislation which bars them from practicing law in South Africa. Photo: Brian Turner via Flickr (CC BY 2.0)

  • Three Zimbabwean-born law graduates, who have fully qualified in South Africa, are challenging a rule that prevents them from professionally practicing law in the country.
  • According to the Legal Practice Act only permanent residents and citizens may be admitted to the profession.
  • The Scalabrini Centre is opposing the Legal Practice Council’s stance, stating that its submissions to the court are “premised on the most vulgar of stereotypes and are simply xenophobic”.
  • In opposing documents, the Legal Practice Council stated that it does not believe the relevant section of the Act is unconstitutional.
  • A Department of Justice representative also argued that the legal profession was not a rare or critical skill and that many South African citizens struggle to get work.

South Africa’s Legal Practice Council (LPC) and the Minister of Justice are opposing a court bid by three Zimbabwean-born graduates to change legislation which bars them from practicing law in South Africa.

Bruce Chakanyuka, Nyasha James Nyamugure and Dennis Tatenda Chadya, with the assistance of the Asylum Seeker Refugee and Migrant Coalition, launched a constitutional challenge of the Legal Practice Act (LPA).

The Act provides only for the enrolment and admission of attorneys and advocates who are either citizens or have permanent residence permits. The trio all have permits which allow them to live, study and work in South Africa. They have also completed their degrees, written board exams and done articles and pupilage.

The matter is pending before the Pretoria High Court.

Three other organisations, the Scalabrini Centre of Cape Town, the Pan African Bar Association and the International Commission of Jurists, have lent support to the trio’s plight. They have asked to be admitted as amicus curiae (friends of the court).

Scalabrini, which promotes and protects the rights of asylum seekers and refugees, has strongly opposed the LPC’s stance, stating that its submissions to the court are “premised on the most vulgar of stereotypes and are simply xenophobic”.

In an affidavit, Executive Director, Guilia Treves, refers to the “extremely concerning justifications” put forward by the LPC in an attempt to justify the blanket exclusion from the legal profession of those who are not citizens or permanent residents.

These include that asylum seekers and refugees are allegedly incapable of acting as officers of the court and with high ethical standards; that they are not fully committed to attaining justice within South Africa; do not respect the laws of South Africa; do not have the necessary appreciation of South African institutions; and are incapable of being regulated by the LPC. It also stated that they are an unreliable drain on the country’s resources.

Treves said it was important for Scalabrini to get involved in the matter to ensure that the voices of this vulnerable group of people be heard.

In opposing documents, LPC chairperson Kathleen Matolo-Dlepu, stated that it does not believe the relevant section of the Act is unconstitutional. She pointed out that the LPC was not the “custodian” of the Act, but merely ensured that legal practitioners comply with provisions. She said that the relief sought by the trio is essentially against the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services.

Matolo-Dlepu said, “Opening the floodgates of persons who wish to practise as attorneys or advocates may lead to abuse, particularly by those who will suddenly be entitled to practise in South Africa by simply obtaining a work permit … this will prejudice legal practitioners who have been admitted to practise.”

She said the courts “should not be burdened with requests to determine policy”. She added that temporary residents were not prevented from working in the legal sector, but only exempted them from being admitted as officers of the court.

“The legal profession involves extraordinary obligations to duty and conscience and requires the highest ethical standards … in order to fulfil their role in the administration of justice and in our society, legal practitioners must be fully committed to South African society. Only citizenship and permanent residency imply such full commitment,” she said.

On behalf of the minister, Kalayvani Pillay, a deputy director in the department of legal services, suggested that the Department of Home Affairs be included in proceedings because the case deals with immigration laws.

Pillay said the legal profession was not a rare or critical skill and many South African citizens struggle to get work.

Nasreen Rajab-Budlender, the national chairperson of the Pan African Bar Association — which set up the Pius Langa School of Advocacy — said if admitted as a friend of the court, it would submit that the exclusion of non-citizens was akin to apartheid policies.

© 2021 GroundUp. This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

You may republish this article, so long as you credit the authors and GroundUp, and do not change the text. Please include a link back to the original article.

We put an invisible pixel in the article so that we can count traffic to republishers. All analytics tools are solely on our servers. We do not give our logs to any third party. Logs are deleted after two weeks. We do not use any IP address identifying information except to count regional traffic. We are solely interested in counting hits, not tracking users. If you republish, please do not delete the invisible pixel.

Source: GroundUp





Previous: Philippi informal settlement residents say they are the “forgotten” community of Cape Town
Next: High school dropout rate blamed on water crisis in Eastern Cape village





Filed Under: GroundUp Tagged With: GroundUp

RSS Events

  • Mozambique’s Moreira Chonguiça Makes Ronnie Scott’s Debut With Two London Jazz Festival Shows
  • Soweto Gets a New Summer Lifestyle Festival as Sugar People & Friends Celebrates Its First Birthday
  • Deftones Setlist: What to Expect From Their 2027 Live Show
  • Hyde Park Corner Brings Out the Stars for This Year’s Spectacular Tree Lighting Celebration!
  • Step Inside: Prudential Center – Home of the New Jersey Devils
  • Exclusive November Imax Lineup Features Iconic Music Legend and a Hollywood Blockbuster
  • Kasi Republic Brings Kwaito, Kasi Cars and Ispantsula Style to Riversands Farm Village This Reconciliation Day
  • Festive Shopping Made Simple at Solly Kramer’s Parkhurst
  • LEDBox Hires Outdoor LED Screen Trailers with On-Site Crew
  • From Busking to the Business of Music: MEX Opens New Doors

About admin

The one with a "My Complex" - incurable but fun. Grumpy, Cynical, Wise and Idiotic. I can also be found HERE.

Footer

Latest News from Africa

  • Prince Albert – the New King of Jazz
  • Eritrea: Independence Cup in Southern Region
  • President El-Sisi Follows-up on the Evacuation of Egyptian Citizens from Sudan
  • United Arab Emirates welcomes initiation of talks between Sudanese Armed Forces and Rapid Support Forces
  • Ghana’s regions: why creating new territories has caused problems
  • Uganda Red Cross Delivers Relief Aid to Kisoro Floods-Affected Communities
  • President Ramaphosa alarmed over conflict, violence in eastern DRC
  • Mental health: almost half of Johannesburg students in new study screened positive for probable depression
  • Dietary Supplements for Dogs and Cats: Enhancing Well-being
  • Midwives scramble to ensure safe deliveries amid violence in Sudan

RSS MyPR’s Free Press Releases

© 2026 MyZA · Port Elizabeth, South Africa | Privacy Policy | MyZA content usage